Comparative literature department of comparative studies. Through his iconoclasm of the patriarchal normalities of 50s society, williams embellishes characters as catalysts for taboo reveals of isolation, sexuality, and femininity. Writing a literary analysis comparison paper youtube. Literature, of course, came into being ages before the first film was produced. Literature and film research papers literature and film research papers discuss the difference between reading a book and watching a movie. Alices adventures in wonderland was an incredible piece of surrealist literature, written by lewis carroll in the dying years of the 19 th century. It is necessary to clarify that the literature teaching. It has since kept its status as one of the most artistic novels of all time, with all sorts of hypnotically brilliant art emerging as a result. She wrote it in 1816, when she went on holiday with her friend, byron. This work discusses the relationship between film and literature, explaining and evaluating the issues most frequently raised on the subject. Alternatively, it might be used as an english course supplement over a number of years from grades seven through twelve.
Did they look the way you thought they were going to in the movie. A comparison of film techniques of two film versions of. Baz luhrmanns kaleidoscopic film adaptation of romeo and juliet, while often leaving much to be desired from the two main actors in the way of delivery, presents a fascinating modern interpretation of the 16th century drama. Department of comparative literature indiana university. Mar 01, 2017 world book day is a unesco worldwide recognised celebration of books and literature, and at raindance every day is a celebration of film and cinema.
There are several uncanny resemblances between the yellow wallpaper and stanley kubricks 1980 horror film the shining. Literature versus film adaptation in 2006, the namesake was adapted into a film directed by mira nair by the same title. Aug 17, 2015 18 movies booklovers will appreciate, because sometimes you just need a little break from literature gasp, i know. As movie adaptations of books go, the film adaptation is very faithful to the novel. Carefully chosen words paint visuals upon a page for the theater of the mind. This has often inspired other, more visually oriented artists to create tangible objects based on these mental images. Nov 08, 2011 i still face a conundrum today with film adaptations, vacillating between seeing the movie first and then reading the book, or vice versa, or even sticking to one option. Literature and film research papers discuss the difference between reading a book and watching a movie. In my experience, the big screen rarely captures the wonder of the written word. Comparing a literary work to its film interpretation.
Some stories have a more visual aspect and work better in movies, and some have a more imaginative aspect and belong in books. Comparative literature transcends national and cultural boundaries offering students a global view of literature. How to write a research paper on literature and film. Contrast of films and literature film studies essay.
To consider the choices directors make, i give students some tools that empower them to talk about film using the language of film. Literature comparison between a short story and a poem gian carlo o. Proseminar in comparative literature taken first term offered b. I still face a conundrum today with film adaptations, vacillating between seeing the movie first and then reading the book, or vice versa, or even sticking to one option. Literature and film comparison the yellow wallpaper and. Movie and book comparison research paper movie and book comparison research papers look at an order placed with the instructions of comparing books with the movies inspired by them. Byron was already a famous poet, and it was him who. Comparative arts is also a perfect complement for preprofessional majors who will want to enjoy the finer things in life e. Using the knowledge gained in class, the differences between literature and film will be explained with a focus on the film and literature of oedipus rex. Use this topic or order a custom research paper, written exactly how you need it to be. Studying the relationship between film and fiction, critics have noted the value and limitation of each medium. Reading standard 7 comparing texts teching the cccs. The differences between novels and films enhance literature. They read the short story, screen the film, discuss reactions to both works, and plan and write a persuasive essay analyzing the validity of the film interpretation.
There are some major discrepancies between the two versions perhaps most significantly is the films lack of character development. This form of entertainment had been around for ages, whether be in a form of a poetry, a drama or a short story. More clearly, using films could facilitate the english literature teaching. Alyssa famiglietti film and literature professor talbird essay 1genre analysis when it came to watching comedy films, i started realizing more and more that theyregenerally all the same story line. This is because, the movie is mainly based on the 1920s play, other than the original mary. Oct 17, 2016 there are several uncanny resemblances between the yellow wallpaper and stanley kubricks 1980 horror film the shining. They investigate ancient and contemporary approaches to literary study, theories and methods of comparison, and the relationship of literature to film and other media. Literature to film comparecontrast essay by elizabeth. Feb 15, 2016 11 words to strike from student writing, literary analysis writing, high school teacher vlog duration. What is undeniable is that the romans, in comparison with the greeks, innovate relatively few literary styles of their own. What are the differences and similarities between film and. The relationship between cinema and literature film studies essay. Celebrating prezis teacher community for teacher appreciation week.
Points of comparison are the traits common to the category. It also lists nearly 2,500 articles and books published from 1908 to 1985 on the comparison of film to drama, fiction, and poetry. Critical essays novel versus film adaptation in 2006, the namesake was adapted into a film directed by mira nair by the same title. However, this has been possible due to numerous reasons, and one of the major reasons is difference between studio and location techniques of television and film that distinguish them from each other. The relationship between cinema and literature film. A comparison of the book and film version of the adventures of huckleberry finn. This document introduces students to some important concepts they need to consider when viewing a film. This play makes you think and shows us how important the theater was and still is as a way of communicating a playwrights ability to build something from the inside out. So it has a more rich lineage, and it has seen many ages, from the epoch of the savages to that of the pos. Films in language teaching the above features of the films actually have great significance in english language teaching. Identify points of comparison and design the thesis statement your thesis should come as a result of brainstorming.
Comparative literature is an interdisciplinary field whose practitioners study literature across national borders, across time periods, across languages, across genres, across boundaries between literature and the other arts music, painting, dance, film, etc. There are more differences than similarities between the book and the movie. In high school and college literature classes, one common type of writing assignment is the comparison and contrast essay. More committed students can major in comparative literature with a focus on comparative arts. You will also engage more complex questions of comparison, translation, and transmission across cultural, linguistic, and national boundaries, and study literature in relation to other disciplines e. This is a topic suggestion on movie and book comparison from paper masters. Sometimes a film combines two books such as in alice in wonderland and through the looking glass or reinterpret a work completely as in kurosawas throne of blood based on macbeth which is a script and to be adapted freely to the theater to begin with, which makes the comparison between a book and a film more. Requirements in comparative literature 6 courses a. Whether it is a film or a piece of literature, both are written by someone that wants to leave an impact on an audience. In the book we see much more of maxs past, and his present. He talks about his dreams of boxing hitler, develops an exercise regimen to occupy his time in the hubermanns basment, and, after discovering liesel. Comparison article about comparison by the free dictionary. Comparative literature and film ba hons canterbury. Comparison meaning in the cambridge english dictionary.
The main idea i will explore will be the effect of isolation on the protagonist of the short story and film, while making direct comparisons supported by close reading. The salesman originally titled forushande is an iranian film that took inspiration from the. Movies as literature uses classic films as material to be used for literary analysis in this fullyear english course for high school students. A comparison of film techniques of two film versions of mary shelleys frankenstein mary shelley wrote her novel frankenstein when she was just a young girl of nineteen. Dela cruz literature comparison between a short story and a poem literature.
Therefore, its the perfect occasion to draw a parallel between these two deeply interconnected art forms that keep inspiring each other and opening their audiences to an endless imaginary world. Literature can, at times, have a fascinating connection with film. You have numerous characters, where something bad happens,or they get put into an obstacle which they need to overcome and of course everything always works out in. Comparison between the film and the book frankenstein 123. You study texts in english translation, including works by such famous authors as homer, ovid, dante, goethe, dostoevsky, balzac, flaubert, proust and kafka, as well as british classics such as shakespeare, dickens, joyce and woolf. It was later adapted into a movie version directed by james whales. Literature and write about a wide variety of literary works across periods, genres, and national traditions. Satire is one of the few roman additions to literaturehorace was the first to use satire extensively as a tool for argument, and juvenal made it into a weapon. Basically, as soon as film existed, they were making movies about frankenstein. Research papers on literary works and their film counterpoints can look at any work of literature and compare it to the film version. World book day is a unesco worldwide recognised celebration of books and literature, and at raindance every day is a celebration of film and cinema. Tennessee williams 1955 play cat on a hot tin roof, explores the avantgrade realities in which facades appear to dispel. This lesson is ideally suited for students who have experience with persuasive writing, and it can be adapted to work with any literaturefilm pairing. Four courses in literary study, each originating in comparative literature or bearing a crosslist number.
Feb 26, 2015 there are some major discrepancies between the two versions perhaps most significantly is the films lack of character development. The differences between novels and filmsenhance literature teaching by using films 61 6 ask the students to list all the similarities and differences in the two sequences in terms of location, character, things happening, attitude, result, etc 7 share the results in the class. Create marketing content that resonates with prezi video. Literature and films have many similarities and differences. Jun 20, 2019 tennessee williams 1955 play cat on a hot tin roof, explores the avantgrade realities in which facades appear to dispel. You have numerous characters, where something bad happens,or they get put into an obstacle which they need to. Essay on literature comparison between a short story and a. Film and literature comparison essay example topics and.